Showing posts with label IDW. Show all posts
Showing posts with label IDW. Show all posts

Thursday, August 29, 2013

Comic Review: Transformers More Than Meets the Eye #20

                Does More Than Meets the Eye retain its title as best comic you’re not yet reading?  Let’s see.


Cover:
                Yes, there are multiple covers (it’s and IDW book so of course there are), and yes I grabbed the one on the top (the Alex Milne cover).  This one depicts Rodimus carrying Tailgate (who has been dying for the last few issues) as they are being chased by the Legislators (personality-less robots that were bred to kill by Tyrest – the main villain in this book as of the last couple issues). 

                I like the art on the cover as it is telling a story while featuring two of the prominent characters from the book.  It also forces us to ask questions if we are a new reader such as “what is chasing Rodimus?” “Why is Rodimus carrying Tailgate?” or just a general “Who are these characters?”  The composition leads us to Rodimus’ face as the main focus of the cover, however the coloring actually forces our eye to the giant bright yellow triangle over his right shoulder.  While I understand that that actually makes sense based upon the overall lighting scheme of the cover in general, it doesn’t help the composition when the coloring is in direct contrast.  That being said, shrouding a good portion of Rodimus’ face in shadow doesn’t help force the eye there either.  This is the unfortunate cross to bear with more “realistic” computer coloring.  If this comic was produced twenty-five years ago, the reds would be red, the white’s would be white and the yellows would be yellow, and distinctions would be able to be made because of it.  Now the Transformers comics are some of the best on the market in terms of combining the lineart with the color to create a cohesive image, but it just doesn’t work well on this cover (which is unfortunate as the cover is where you want it to work the most).  There is also a slight tangent if you look at the tip of Tailgate’s right foot and Rodimus’ knee.  This is exacerbated by the fact that they are pretty much the same color as well, so even with the heavier outline it is difficult to determine where one stops and the other begins.

                The only other gripe that I have is with the signature.  It’s huge!  Believe me, I’m all for signing your artwork and taking ownership of it in terms of receiving the due credit, but holy crap.  This is along the same lines as the 1990s Todd McFarlane or Greg Capullo signatures that were, at times, oppressive to the artwork itself.  While Milne at least kept his signature confined to the lower right corner (and he avoided putting a box or some other device around it to draw even more attention to it) the signature itself is just too involved in the artwork, and something that should be present but not oppressive is quite the opposite.  

6/10 – While the overall design is good, the execution hurts the image. 

Story:
                The story by James Roberts is nearing its conclusion, something that has been building up since issue number one.  Reading a lot of the Transformers comics every month, it took me a little time to remember what happened in the last issue.  The “story so far” box on the inside front cover helps a bit, but seeing the ramifications of the events unfold as jump cuts on the first page caused me to pause and search my memory banks for some semblance of what happened last issue.  While I am glad that there is a page in the back specifically dedicated to showing each of the Transformers involved in that story (especially since this book doesn’t use a whole lot of the traditional Transformers that we all know and love) not having that info available at the outset causes me to try and remember who everyone is, and sometimes the color-scheme and designs are so similar that it becomes confusing. 

                The story itself is great.  It doesn’t really tie up any loose ends as much as it forces them to their next logical stage before the conclusion.  Roberts does an excellent job of juggling at least four different aspects to the story, each part focusing on different characters and then bringing nearly all of them together by the end, ensuring that the final part is laser focused.  When you have a stable of characters, both heroes and villains, in which to pull from, it may seem difficult to develop some of the lesser known characters and give them the same weight that a franchise staple would have.  Take for example Tyrest, the villain.  When you have villains such as Megatron, Shockwave, or Bludgeon at your disposal, building up Tyrest to that kind of level might seem like an insurmountable task, but Roberts does it, and it only takes a few short issues to do it.  His actions, and more importantly the motivations for those actions, are as heinous as anything you would expect to see from any of the aforementioned villains.  Roberts writes him as almost a delusional cult leader, with his actions being justified (in his own mind anyway) by the fact that they will bring him closer to eternal light.  The fact that there may be actual credence to his claims by the end of the issue is a shock in its own right. 

                Not only do we get all of that story development, but Roberts also takes the time to weave in character development for Skids, everyone’s favorite memory wiped Autobot.  We as readers finally get to learn how Skids got in the condition he’s in (think Men in Black memory wiping device, but with the ability to implant a thought or suggestion in the brain of the target).  It’s actually a bit more complicated than that, but it brings us back to Tyrest and shows that he has been in the thick of things from the beginning.  The fact that Roberts said that this “Remain in Light” storyline was the big payoff to all of the previous issues, and then to actually exhibit the skill  to pull off that bold claim is incredibly impressive.  Roberts is by far one of the best writers in the business today, and hopefully IDW can keep him attached to this book for a long time to come.

9/10 – The story itself is top notch, the little parts in the beginning where things just progress naturally from the last issue takes a couple panels to get used to.  The cliffhanger ending is one of the best I have seen in recent memory, and actually gets me excited to read a comic book again (who knew that was possible).

Art:
                Alex Milne, with Brian Shearer’s assistance on the inks and Josh Burcham and John-Paul Bove on colors, provide another artistic tour de force.  I’m not going to lie, sometimes the artwork can be a bit confusing with all of the different moving parts going on, but the fact that Milne and Co. pack so much into each page, hell, each panel and it doesn’t become an unintelligible mess speaks to their own individual abilities.  Milne is a master of expression with these characters as well, making them feel more like human beings in disguise as opposed to giant hunks of metal.  The thing that makes me hesitant to really embrace Andrew Wildman’s classic Transformers work (the stiff blocky nature and overall feel that everything looks like the old toys) is the exact opposite here.  There is so much movement in the characters as well as the overall design of the panels that everything feels organic and animated. 

                Milne also does a good job of mixing up camera angles in this one.  He still tends to rely too much on midrange shots, with very few, if any, long establishing shots thrown into the mix, which is either a blessing or a curse with his amount of detailed work.  Even without the long shots, he does a decent job of changing the angle of the camera up enough to ensure that the exact same shot is not repeated over multiple panels (unless it’s for dramatic effect). 

9/10 – Milne is the quintessential Transformers artist in my opinion and regardless of the title he works on I will be a longtime fan of his work.

Overall:  9/10 – The cover aside, this book was a masterpiece of storytelling.  Showing how to successfully move a story along (and actually move it along, not just give the impression that it is) while setting up the next issue to blow the minds of the readers.  I don’t know why I have to repeat myself by now, but if you aren’t reading this series, pick it up now.

Thursday, August 22, 2013

Comic Review – KISS Kids #1

                I have railed against the comic industry on numerous occasions for being to focused on their aging readers and not really doing much to attract new readers to their product.  While, in general, I think that still holds true, this week’s entry helps to soften that blow a bit.


Cover:
                I picked up the Bruce Timm cover as it was the first one visible as well as the one I wanted anyway.  What can I say about Bruce Timm the artist that hasn’t already been said?  Regardless of the subject matter, his style is undeniable.  Seriously, this looks like Gene Simmons stepped right out of the Batman the Animated Series cartoon (and how awesome would that be if KISS was included).  This fits incredibly well with the overall tone of the book as it is definitely going for a more light hearted, animated feel, and who better to give you an animated feel than the father of DC’s animated universe.  Timm does a great job of providing not only the animated “feel” but also capturing the likeness and, more importantly, the personality of Simmons.  The way that Timm, using just lines, can indicate multiple different textures within the piece without making everything overly detailed or pushing the piece out of his characteristic style shows a grasp of the tools that are well beyond what most cartoonists could ever hope to accomplish. 

                The cover is very generic, but it has a feel that you just can’t get anywhere else.  The colors from Rom Fajardo are a little muddy, but they don’t do too much to detract from the overall illustration. 

9/10 – I have a feeling if Timm came back to comics full time (as in doing a whole book and not just covers/pinups) people would line up around the block for their chance to pick it up.  He is that good at what he does.

Story:
                The story, by Chris Ryall and Tom Waltz (the guys that have written pretty much every other KISS comic for IDW over the past year) is actually a collection of short stories, ranging from one to five pages.  While I wasn’t overly impressed by IDW’s other KISS comics, the simple fact that these two writers can go from such a heavy-handed concept, built almost exclusively for adults, to something for kids that actually works well speaks to their abilities as writers.  It’s also nice to see that the two writers have fleshed out the characters enough that regardless of who the writer is, the characters have the same “voice”. 

                The stories are pretty typical in terms of things that you would think might happen to kids, just with a spin on it to take advantage of the subject matter (sixteen year old Christine is the babysitter, Gene’s favorite birthday present is money, etc.).  The whole thing has a very Calvin and Hobbes feel to it and is incredibly accessible to kids.  I can easily see this generation of children running around pretending to be Li’l Demon or Spacey with their friends. 

                While the decision to include KISS kid robots as the bullies seems a little corny, it does make more sense than trying to shoehorn in some KISS-related villains (though why there isn’t a “Wicked Lester” yet, I don’t know).  Besides that, though, everything is pretty seamless in terms of the transition from adults to kids.

8/10 – This may be the most fun KISS-related series since Psycho Circus was in its heyday. 

Art:
                Jose Holder does a great job on the art duties for the most part.  The kids themselves are well thought out and provide both an accurate representation of the KISS makeup while “smoothing the edges” so to speak for the younger audience.  The storytelling and pacing are well done with an abundance of well-drawn backgrounds that serve to ground the cartoony characters in reality.  The quality of Holder’s artwork is steady throughout the book as well.  From story to story, page to page, he remains incredibly consistent with his linework and character models. 

                The one place where Holder seems to fall flat is his representation of “normal” people, especially adults.  The fact that they are so much different in style to the KISS kids really prevents everything from gelling together.  It’s fine if the backgrounds are realistically represented, but once you make the other humans take on similar realistic characteristics, it makes the KISS kids stick out like a sore thumb.   

8/10 – This feels like almost the perfect project for Holder, who really shines here on the artwork.

Overall: 8/10 – If you are looking for something to read with your kids, this is definitely it.

Thursday, August 8, 2013

Comic Review: Transformers Robots in Disguise #20

                Another Transformer’s book this week?  You bet.  Buckle up.


Cover:
                This issue deals with the aftermath of the Decepticon uprising and the crowning of Starscream as the new ruler of the Transformers (there are no longer Autobot and Decepticon factions allowed within city limits as Starscream has banished all that were unwilling to throw down those monikers).  Fittingly, all of the covers of this issue prominently feature Starscream.  The cover I picked up (the first one visible) had Starscream standing over the fallen body of Metalhawk, Starscreams “friend” that he killed to further his own personal and political agenda during the last story arc.  This is a poignant moment that relates quite a bit to the book itself as the beginning of the story is Starscream speaking to his dead friend, explaining his actions and the motivations for those actions.  I am a big fan of the stark white background and the way that the figures and Starscream’s cast shadow pop out against it. 

                One major thing to look at in terms of a cover is obviously composition.  Is it composed in a way that draws you in, that makes it an interesting image as opposed to just a stock shot of the characters presented?  This cover by Andrew Griffith does that masterfully, combining a narrative with a shot that you don’t always see on covers (a downshot).  The fact that Griffith went with this particular angle also helps to show Starscream’s importance and prominence.  Not only is he the figure closest to us, but if you combine his figure with his cast shadow it makes a larger, almost suffocating presence on the cover, which works well considering the fact that he has that presence in the book at times. 

9/10 – The cover conveys a powerful message about the rest of the book, especially considering that Starscream is standing over the fallen body of Metalhawk as a victor and not kneeling as a friend might do.  This mixes a strong design sense with the ability to tell a story, something most modern covers just don’t do anymore.

Story:
                This definitely feels like a filler issue.  That’s not necessarily meant as a bad thing either.  It’s just the fact that past issues have been so chock full of action and development that a quieter issue like this is going to feel a little weaker by comparison.  I see that John Barber is starting a slow build up to the Dark Cybertron storyline that will be taking over soon, but this issue definitely feels like it is there to get us to the next issue and not much more (until the cliffhanger at the end).   This issue does a good job of wrapping things up from the previous storyline, but it almost feels like the last forty minutes of The Return of the King.  It’s nice to have but it doesn’t really add a whole lot.

                I like the fact that as Starscream has kind of usurped Megatron’s place as leader, he now has a bot come along and take his place in the form of Rattrap.  Someone that is scheming and sneaking and looking out for his own interests, as Starscream had done throughout the entirety of his existence up to this point.  How Starscream deals with Rattrap moving forward is setting up to be an interesting plotline.  Beyond the introduction of Rattrap (and the subsequent actions to show us that he is basically the new Starscream) and the reveal at the end (a fan favorite is not as dead as you thought he was) this was a pretty tame read.

5/10 – It’s setting things in motion, but compared to the last few issues (and especially compared to its sister title More Than Meets the Eye) it feels kind of boring. 

Art:
                Andrew Griffith provides the art here and it is, as always, well executed.  The level of detail that encompasses every page and every panel of the book, along with the ability for Griffith to transpose human emotion on the faces of these hunks of metal makes for a good read.  He does a great job of taking something that can be clunky and hard to emote feel almost human.  There are artists out there that can’t convey that kind of acting and emotion with human characters as well as Griffith can with robots.

                Griffith does tend to dwell in the middleground in terms of his shot selection though.  He doesn’t usually take the camera to the extremes, which can lead to a bit of a stagnant and boring comic at times.  While I understand that an extreme close up is not always necessary in a story like this that is mainly exposition, backing the camera up and giving us an establishing shot, or just letting the characters breathe a little is something that would be both appreciated and welcomed.

                The coloring does tend to get a little muddy at times as well, especially in the outdoor sequences at night.  A dark blue sky against the dark colors of the various Transformers just tends to lead to an overall dark panel or page (and it doesn’t help that Griffith tends to lay out his panels so that they are smaller and have a large white border around the page itself instead of having the images bleed off the page).  This contrast would look good if it didn’t just highlight the fact that the panels themselves were so dark.

7/10 – The linework and actual drawing is as good as ever by Griffith.  I’d like to see more attention paid to pacing the story a bit better and using the wide range of shots available instead of settling into three or four different medium shots.  The coloring is a bit dark and muddy as well.

Overall: 6/10 – This isn’t the best issue of the series but it serves its purpose to get us to the next chapter while putting a bow on the previous storyline. 

Thursday, August 1, 2013

Comic Review: Transformers More Than Meets The Eye #19

                In light of certain recent financial restrictions, I am only reviewing comics that I would normally purchase during a given week for the foreseeable future.  We dip back into the Transformers well again this week, reviewing the newest issue of probably my favorite book being produced right now.


Cover:
                It took two comic stores for me to even find this issue (Syracuse comic shops, what are you gonna do?) and when I did, I grabbed the last copy available.  I didn’t have my choice of covers, but I think I got the better end of the deal anyway as the Sean Chen cover is very well done.  The cover is actually more than just a pinup of two characters (in this case Whirl and Cyclonus) and actually depicts a part of the story from the comic itself (as many of the Transformers comics tend to do).  All of the angles present here, between swords and Whirl himself do more to help the eye move around the page than they do to hinder it (which is the exact opposite of what you would assume).  Those angles serve to frame the figures and take what could have been a very static, boring cover and jazz it up a bit.  Don’t get me wrong, it still feels a little generic, but the flourishes that Chen provides, including the details on the swords themselves, serve to distract, at least momentarily from the relatively standard cover.

                Something should be said for the linework and detail put into the characters.  While it’s a bit of a departure from what we are used to seeing in the interiors (which are usually left more open for color) this works incredibly well, and I would buy the shit out of a Sean Chen illustrated Transformers book.

8/10 – Incredible art jazzes up a generic cover.  In the hands of a less experienced or talented artist this would have been a flop of epic proportions.  Chen makes it work with an almost Travis Charest level of attention to detail.

Story:
                The art on Transformers comics rarely disappoints, but I’ll tell you something: the writing on this batch of titles is some of the best I have ever read (and I’ve been reading comics for a looooong time).  This issue is right up there with the old Claremount-era X-Men books in terms of fitting so much together into one issue.  James Roberts has been building this universe and everything feels like it is starting to pay off as old mysteries are starting to be solved (what’s up with the lack of memory for Skids) while new and interesting narratives are being started (the fact that Ultra Magnus is an ideal, not a person anymore (that was incredible), the Ratchet/Pharma dick measuring contest that takes an unexpected and unfortunate turn, Whirl and Cyclonus finding and freeing the Circle of Light, and the artist formerly known as Ultra Magnus confronting Tyrest take place in this regular sized issue. All of this is on top of the fact that we are still watching the clock tick down on Tailgate in terms of his life expectancy, and it just keeps you on the edge of your seat for the entire book.

                Roberts does an incredible job of juggling every single storyline without letting any feel jilted in any way.  He takes what could have been mass confusion and chaos and uses that to craft a mood where we feel like we are with the captive Autobots.  He expertly handles every big reveal (and there are a lot of them) while moving the story along naturally and with all of the humor and flair that you are used to when he puts pen to paper. 

10/10 – Roberts continues to live up to the lofty expectations he has put into place throughout the series.  Between plot, pacing and dialogue he is firing on all cylinders.

Art:
                Alex Milne (with inks by Brian Shearer) do an incredible job of keeping the artwork at a consistently high level throughout the book.  The settings are all the same, but there are so many characters and so many moments that you could easily see the art team focusing on their favorites and letting the quality slip in other parts of the book.  Milne is as consistent as they come, providing crisp, clean artwork that works so well with the coloring (done by Josh Burcham) that you would think he does it all himself. 

                Actually, I need to take a minute to single out Burcham because of the work he does on this title.  Milne’s pencils cannot be the easiest things to color and still maintain some semblance of separation based on the lack of solid black in his artwork.  It pretty much all falls to Burcham (there’s not much Shearer can do in terms of spotting lacks without taking away from the style of the artwork in general) to provide us with the feeling of space, grounding each scene in “reality” while also providing separation between objects in the foreground and background (both with so many components that most normal colorists would either go crazy or say to hell with it and just start throwing solid colors around).  Burcham’s design sense as well as his ability to interpret the artwork is something that cannot be understated here.  For a visual sample of that, look no further than the sequence where Whirl and Cyclonus are infiltrating a weapons cache.  There is an alarm sounding and a red light flashing, bathing the entire scene in a red glow.  Without the ability to use various colors as separation mechanisms, the characters tend to get lost in the background elements.  Burcham is kind of hamstrung by the color palette, I understand that, but it does a good job of highlighting what Milne’s artwork could be like in less capable hands.

9/10 – Never underestimate a good artist-colorist combination.  These guys are at the top of their game and the art itself marries perfectly with the script from Roberts to create a cohesive masterpiece.

Overall: 9/10 – There’s a reason this hasn’t relinquished the crown of “favorite comic” in my current library.  All of the creators involved are performing at a high level, and the fact that Hasbro and IDW are letting the characters be (seemingly) killed off and altered significantly shows that they believe in the creators, which goes a long way when it comes to licensed comics. 

Thursday, July 25, 2013

Comic Review: Transformers Prime Beast Hunters #3

                You’re going to have to bear with me for a few weeks as the funds are getting tighter than normal around here.  I’m going to have to stick to reviewing comics that I would normally have bought anyway as no comic shops in the area seem willing to pony up a $4 floppy every week in exchange for some free publicity.  Seriously, if you want to see more in depth reviews of different books, just call up the comic shops in the Syracuse area and tell them to loosen up a bit.  That being said, the next few months we’re going to see a lot of Transformers reviews as that is the bulk of my purchases now.  We start it off with the one book that I have yet to review, Transformers Prime Beast Hunters.



Cover:
                All of the covers to this series are produced by Ken Christiansen and they all have a certain feel to them like they are right out of the Transformers Prime television show.  Obviously this is a huge plus as the comic touts its connection to the show from the get-go.  None of the covers to the comics (this one included) seem to have much in common with the story being told, almost as if they gave Christiansen a bunch of characters and told him to go nuts and they would fit the covers in wherever. As far as covers not pertaining to the story go, these are incredibly solid though.  This current cover features three of the Dinobots surrounded by Decepticons that are masked by shadows.  You can tell that they are Decepticons because of the symbol on their chest as well as the fact that they are glowing purple (the popular Decepticon color-scheme). 

                While the lack of holding lines on the artwork itself can lead to some muddled moments in terms of the artwork blending together, there is enough variation using light to make the characters separate ever so slightly from the background.  The movement within the three figures on the cover shows a great design sense as your eye moves fluidly throughout the image.  One would think that with the way that the characters are colored, combined with the blocky nature of Transformers in general that it would be a bit more difficult to achieve that kind of movement but Christiansen does it easily.

8/10 – I have to give it a knock for being a bit generic, but it has its own narrative qualities and a phenomenal design sense. 

Story:
                The general story of this series is that the Dinobots are left on Cybertron after everyone else leaves (which you can see the lead up to in the video game, Transformers War for Cybertron and the aftermath in the Transformers Prime television show) and they are not only trying to hold society together, but also to find out more about themselves as they have been subjected to numerous experiments at the hands of the Decepticon Shockwave.  The first two issues were more along the lines of keeping the peace on Cybertron while this issue starts to deal more with the basic origin of the Dinobots themselves.  While I am intrigued as to where the story will go, there is not much to this issue itself and it turns out to be a pretty quick read. 

Storytellers Mike Johnson and Mairghread Scott (and specifically Mike Johnson who actually wrote the issue) may have something bigger that this is leading up to, but after the last two issues that had a lot going on and felt like they really lived up to the Transformers moniker on the cover in terms of quality, seem to fall a bit flat here.  The big reveal at the end, where Grimlock and Swoop are fighting against actual dinosaurs is probably a bit of fanservice as who doesn’t want to se Grimlock fight an actual T-Rex, but it raises more questions than answers in terms of carbon-based life forms and their ability to exist on Cybertron.  Considering the fact that this brawl happened at the end of the issue, I will give Johnson an issue to work out the details of atmosphere, time (as the Dinobots have been in operation in their current iteration for a little while in the comic universe, so how did the dinosaurs survive, much less know how and when to break out at this convenient moment) and overall luck as Grimlock and Swoop just happen to be patrolling near Shockwave’s lab that spawned the Dinobots.

                Again, I will give Johnson the benefit of the doubt that after the dust settles we will start to receive answers to these questions and that everything won’t seem as “convenient” as it is presented here.  Other than that, the dialogue is good, with the interaction between Grimlock and Swoop staying true to their character and really playing up their own distinct “roles” within the Dinobots.

6/10 – The quality dips a bit in this issue, especially after the very well done first two, but it does set up a lot of questions to add to the mythos and keep us coming back for more.  I just wish it took longer than ten minutes to read.

Art:
                Agustin Padilla provides the art here and while it is miles away from the art we see in other Transformers comics nowadays, it is still very good.  The ability to consistently draw these characters in all their glory, both in robot and their “alt” modes cannot be understated, and while the Dinobots don’t turn into vehicles (which would be the bane of my existence) drawing the robotic dinosaurs is no easy task either.  Padilla handles this admirably and adds his own bit of flair in making the art darker and grittier than his counterparts in the other titles. 

                While Padilla does draw everything well, robots and actual dinosaurs alike, my main problem is the utilization of space on the page.  There are many times where Padilla will leave a lot of space around the figures, almost as if he is expecting a lot of dialogue to be added and he was making room for it.  When that dialogue is not added it just looks like poor pacing on his part as the panel could have usually been shrunk while others were expanded.  Now, don’t get me wrong, there is a background in nearly every panel, so even though there is a big space, it is not necessarily devoid of something, however looking at a large metal wall that has no bearing on the story is not really useful in any way.  I am not sure if this is the fault of Padilla or Johnson, the writer just not filing the space (I don’t know the scripting method used so can’t make that determination with any certainty).

7/10 – The art is a nice change of pace from the clean lines and open figures of most of the other Transformers titles.  Padilla does a great job of breaking up the different surfaces with a variety of textures as well. 

Overall: 8/10 – While this isn’t the best issue in the series, if you have even a passing interest in the franchise or the Dinobots, you should be reading this series.  It’s easy to see how Transformers stories have been told for nearly thirty years now.

Thursday, June 20, 2013

Comic Review – Transformers Monstrosity #1

                Like a good little drone I will usually plunk my hard earned money down for at least one issue of any Transformers comic that IDW releases.  This is not purely a nostalgia-based purchase (for that you can look no further than DC’s Masters of the Universe line) as these are some of the best comics on the stand today.  The writing is generally spot-on in terms of not only adhering to the particular “voice” I remember these characters having in my youth, but the art is also some of the best in the business.  To be able to take such complex forms and make them not only readable but fluid within a comic book setting is not an easy thing.  Hell I can’t even do it in a pinup, I have no idea how some of these artists do it for an entire book.

                That being said, let’s look at the latest mini-series to drop in the Transformers line.  Monstrosity actually started out as a webcomic (much like its predecessor Autocracy – which I still have to pick up) and is being collected for print.  While the ethics of this are probably fairly dubious at best (you can’t tell me that the “talent” is being paid for the digital, print, and eventual trade paperback versions of the story – or, you can I just won’t believe you) it’s interesting to see how the transition is made from digital to print.

This says issue 3 but it's actually the third cover of issue one of the print comic.

Cover:
                It wouldn’t be an IDW book without multiple covers.  This one has three standard covers all by interior artist Livio Ramondelli.  I picked the one that was on top of the pile when I went shopping for it, which was the cover showcasing the dinobots (or as they are called here: the dynobots).  I flipped through the stack just to see the other covers and was happy with my choice.  Covers A and B feature Megatron and Scorponok, respectively and while they are well done, I have a soft spot for the dinobots.  The cover itself shows a pretty standard dinobot pose that is rendered in the standard Ramondelli way. 

                While I enjoy the subject matter, the execution leaves a little to be desired.  The one major flaw in Ramondelli’s work as a whole is that because of the lack of outlines, everything tends to blend together.  This is the main flaw here, and the background having a yellowish tint to it is a poor choice given the yellow on the ‘bots themselves.  Beyond that, the actual figures look off in terms of the perspective on their individual pieces, especially Swoop in the back and Sludge on the left side.  I realize that with so many different pieces that make up your standard Transformer, it is hard to keep everything in order to the point of perfection when it comes to perspective, yet there are too many instances in this cover that just look…off. 

6/10 – It looks like a lot of time was spent on Grimlock because he is in the foreground with less and less being spent on each of the characters as they get further into the distance.  While that makes sense to a point, the foundation should still be there.

Story:
                The execution of the story and how it was transferred from just a set of episodes to one coherent comic book was of interest to me.  Obviously there is an overarching story going through it, but how the writing team of Chris Metzen and Flint Dille was going to synch up each installment and make it cohesive was of great interest to me.  Would this feel like a comic book or just a series of collected pages? 

                The good thing is that there is a lot going on here, and I mean a lot.  We are following at least four major storylines that will undoubtedly intersect sooner rather than later.  This obviously helps when it comes to the individual episodes and would create a natural transition point from the start of each page.  However in a collected format, that could lead to almost a schizophrenic feel, which is what I would hope to avoid if I was the writer.  At first, the transition is not that big of a deal, especially since we are being exposed to many different characters, settings and conflicts.  It’s almost expected to have many jump cuts in that section.  However, once the action slows down a bit in terms of introductions, one would expect to have a little more time with the characters where everything can be fleshed out a bit more.  While Metzen and Dille do a great job of living within the confines of their media while still moving the story along, it is jarring to be someplace new with pretty much every turn of the page. 

                One of the main requirements for producing a Transformers comic is being able to work with a huge cast.  Even if you were to focus on a small, recognizable group of Transformers, all of the bit players would have a distinct voice and would be recognizable to someone, so you would have to try and adhere to that voice.  This is one thing that Metzen and Dille do incredibly well.  They could use the excuse that this takes place right after the war and before the original cartoon that many people use as the basis for the characters as an excuse to alter the personalities of the characters, but they don’t (at least not yet).  The only characters that seem different are the dinobots, but I’m not sure if that’s not because they have some kind of ulterior motive (but I’m sure that will be revealed). 

7/10 – While the transfer from digital to print is not as seamless as I would like it to be, it’s a good story and this issue provides a great framework for the rest of the series.  With so many moving pieces it will be interesting to see how they all fit together. 

Art:
                Any complaints about Ramondelli’s cover art can also be transferred to his interiors.  That being said, Ramondelli does an exceptional job of switching up the color palette to reflect not only the specific group featured in each particular scene, but also the mood in each scene.  This is something that Ramondelli has always excelled at in his Transformers artwork.  The main problem is a decided lack of clarity in his work based upon the lack of outlines and the color palette that he chooses.  This may not be as big of an issue when the comics are digitally presented, but when printed they look like a collection of blobs broken up by word balloons in many instances.  Where the images are legible, they more often than not, look more like paper cut-outs than three dimensional objects.  It’s almost as if removing the outlines had the opposite effect on the artwork. 

                Ramondelli does a decent job of providing action and storytelling where legible.  The characters are almost instantly recognizable and their form stays consistent throughout the entirety of the issue.  Ramondelli does a great job of mixing up camera angles and not letting the storytelling become stagnant and boring.  He prominently features both close-ups and full body shots with great regularity. 

6/10 – There are some very good things here.  The pages are well constructed, and possibly in the original platform they were very legible.  Here, not as much.

Overall: 7/10 – The story is great and the art is good enough for me to continue with this limited series.  I would suggest checking it out if you are already a fan of the Transformers, or if you are intrigued about dinobots or the terrorcons.

Thursday, April 11, 2013

Comic Review: KISS Solo #1


            I have reviewed a few of IDW’s KISS comics in the past, giving both glowing and terrible reviews to the issues.  I was intrigued by this new release as the series that started out in a promising way nearly a year ago, ended with quite the thud, and Mars Attacks KISS was a disaster.  I hoped that a new series focusing on the individual members in their own issues might help writer Chris Ryall flex his muscle and do an introspective journey into each character without giving them such a high stakes assignment like saving the world.  In essence, this could hopefully get the characters back to being an interesting group of characters for the launch of whatever series comes next.  Let’s see how they did.


Cover:
            I’m not going to lie, one of the main things that drew me in to this title in particular is the inclusion of Angel Medina.  I know that there have been KISS comics before and since, but Medina’s run as penciller on the KISS: Psycho Circus comics from Image in the 90’s cement his status in my mind as the definitive KISS artist in comics.  He has a dynamic drawing ability that I loved on his Warlock and the Infinity Watch stuff for Marvel but that really came through when he was allowed to cut loose at Image.  I hoped that by including him in this project, it could bring back some of the mojo that made those Psycho Circus comics some of the most interesting and impressive in the long history (KISStory?) of KISS comics.  Not only was Medina the artist on this first issue focusing on The Demon (the Gene Simmons persona) but he also did the covers for all four issues.

            This cover has all of the same magic that the Psycho Circus comics carried.  The only thing that is any different in fact is that the comic takes place in the city as opposed to the more urban settings of Psycho Circus (it was in a circus after all).  Combine a dynamic pose with an insane amount of detail on The Demon’s armor (a Medina hallmark) as well as a well drawn city in the background and you get a classic cover.  It’s like a Spiderman or Batman cover mixed with Spawn (which Medina also penciled for a while).  This takes me back to the 90’s in a good way, not in the kind of way that seeing a character with too many pockets and chronically obscured feet does. 

10/10 – Maybe I’m a sucker for seeing one of my favorite artists from my youth returning to one of my favorite properties from my youth, but I thoroughly enjoyed this cover.

Story:
            Chris Ryall has been hit or miss with the KISS property in my opinion.  I know that he is also the editor in chief at IDW, so anything negative I say could and probably would hold him back from giving me any kind of work on two properties (KISS and Transformers) that I would love to have a hand in.  That being said, and I am being totally genuine here, this issue is a huge step up from where the series left off.  As I suspected, exploring the characters one on one is a lot more effective than just throwing them out there in a “let’s save the world” scenario.  I will say, having an appearance by the four horsemen of the apocalypse seemed like it was shoehorned in to take advantage of Medina’s design skills and his ability to draw action sequences.  There is not much gleaned from that that could not have been done in a different, less formulaic way (unless of course this leads to a bigger, over-arching plot point to draw the four issues together).  The fact that The Demon gives us a running commentary about how he is beating the horsemen is nice and brings me back to a more 90’s style comic, where exposition of this nature was the norm.  I know that a lot of people don’t like it nowadays, their big argument being that there is no way that that much dialogue can be generated in the time to perform the action depicted on the page.  To this I say: you’re reading a comic book.  Settle down, have a beverage and quit finding fault in something that was industry standard before there was an industry. 

            That being said, this is not nearly as dialogue heavy as you would think.  It definitely gives Medina’s art room to breathe and flow throughout the page.  Knowing that Medina is the main draw here, Ryall does a great job of crafting a story that fits his strengths (even though it doesn’t really work exceptionally well as a story on its own, as a vehicle it is great).  It is full of fighting and opportunities to provide dynamic poses of The Demon and those that he is fighting against.  As always, Ryall works in some classic KISS easter eggs for us diehard fans, using song titles at key points in the story as a shout out to the roots of the series.  The best part is that Ryall knows what songs are “Gene” songs and makes sure to use those.  I hope that he continues that tradition in the later issues and with the same kind of knowledge and care that he did here. 

6/10 – It’s no Psycho Circus, but what is at this point?  This definitely had a similar feel to those stories though (and I’m sure a lot of that had to do with Medina) and Ryall did a good job of letting the art be the highlight here and giving at a vehicle to do so.  There are a couple good parts but nothing that really jumps out at me.  Definitely one of the better issues in the IDW series though.

Art:
            It’s Angel Medina!  On KISS!  What’s not to love!?

            Ok, there’s a couple things that I can mention that stood out to me in a negative way.  Every page is made up of inset panels (much like in last week’s review) and while this is not nearly as confusing for this issue (mainly because the colorist – Romulo Fajardo – does a better job of differentiating the panels with color, it is still something that I skewered the artist for last week, so as much as I love Medina’s work I can’t let him skate by on that.  There’s an incredible amount of movement and detail in each of the panels so that is a positive, plus the fact that Fajardo does an excellent job of coloring straight from Medina’s pencils. 

            The four horsemen themselves are not very unique in their appearance either.  War (as a woman in this iteration which is interesting to see) looks like a Starfire knock-off, Famine looks like a differently-colored Darkseid with some odd prosthesis while Pestilence and Death look like characters in an obscure Japanese fighting video game.  The amount of detail is great but Medina’s overall character designs for these four is just not up to par with what I would expect.  Medina does do a remarkable job of storytelling though and actually keeps everything clear while still making it intensely detailed. 

7/10 – A solid effort by one of the better artists out there that deserves more work than he’s getting.  There’s got to be a horror property for Dark Horse or something that he can work on!

Overall:  7/10 – I have no idea what to expect from the other issues in the “solo” series, but this one was not bad.  I hope that Ryall can build on how much better this one was written than the previous issues in subsequent series starring these characters.

Thursday, April 4, 2013

Comic Review - Transformers Spotlight: Trailcutter


            It’s another installment of the Transformers Spotlight series.  This time with 100% more Trailcutter!


Cover:
            Cover “A” by Matt Frank (the interior artist) does a great job of giving us an idea of what is actually going on in the issue itself.  The other covers are stock illustrations of Trailcutter, so I am lucky that I grabbed the “good” cover to evaluate.  It’s Trailcutter versus the Insecticons!  While Trailcutter in the comic itself is a little more confident than what he shows on the cover, it is a decent representation of what we are going to see.  The design is fairly effective, giving us a feeling that Trailcutter is being swarmed and overwhelmed just by making the shapes on the top darker and therefore more foreboding.  Not only that, but everything points right to Trailcutter on the cover, making sure that he remains our focus.

            I really enjoy the coloring on this by Josh Perez and the way that he (and Frank) balance the heavy shadows on the top with virtually no shadows on the body of Trailcutter himself.  The force field effect is impressive as well as it leaves an orange highlight on everything that is most intense on his hands, where it emanates from. 

8/10 – A nice sense of claustrophobia and dread created by the design and exceptional coloring make this an impressive and powerful cover.

Story:
            The story by James Roberts, part of the writing juggernaut of the two regular titles, highlights a character that we just do not see much of in the more than meets the eye book.  This is a problem with books, and universes, that contain so many characters.  It is hard to feature all of them in the light that they deserve while also moving the story along at an adequate pace.  This is why the inclusion of these Spotlight issues was a good thing.  Not only do they highlight certain characters that do not get a whole lot of facetime in the regular issues (Megatron and Bumblebee issues notwithstanding) but it also gives us little glimpses into the world that we were not privy to before.  They are “side quests” or “downloadable content” to borrow phrases from other media.  These stories are not essential to understanding or enjoying the bigger narrative, but they are nice additions that help to flesh it out more. 

            Roberts, as he does in the regular series, does a masterful job of making sure that we know who everyone is while also moving the story along.  He is almost Claremontian in his ability and willingness to just slip the names of the characters into the dialogue instead of expecting the readers to recognize and know the characters on their own.  Every issue is someone’s first is a great mantra to live by and it feels like Roberts lives by this.  The story itself is a pretty standard tale of someone wanting recognition, and having to save his peers in order to get it.  When you have a property as old and far-reaching as Transformers, sometimes it’s necessary to dig back into the vault of story tropes, as long as you put your own spin on it.  This Roberts does with a great amount of success, blending action and humor together, along with his knowledge and obvious love for the universe to create a tale that is all his own.  Trailcutter (known as Trailbreaker until he changes his name midway through) has a powerful forcefield that is what sets him apart from the other Autobots.  He is known for this and while it helps the “cause” he gets very little recognition for it because it’s just “what he does”.  It would be the same as awarding you or I for breathing.  When he realizes that he is the only ‘bot on the ship without any kind of recognition, something that Rodmius, the captain of the ship, seems to be handing out like it’s no big deal, he pouts.  While he is wallowing in his self pity though, the insecticons attack, disabling everyone on the ship (basically freezing them all in place).  Trailcutter is safe though and goes out to meet the challenge head on.  When he realizes that the only thing that he relies on in battle, his forcefield, is disabled, he relies on his wits to outsmart and subdue the insecticons.  He saves the ship and the crew and gets the recognition he deserves by the end of the issue (though Rodimus is apparently handing out bigger awards by that time much to his chagrin). 

            As you can see, pretty standard story, and one that you have probably seen in one form or another many times over.  The dialogue, character progression and the way that Roberts ties it back into the universe takes something that could be seen as tired and unimaginative and changes it into an interesting and fun done-in-one story. 

9/10 – Just because you start with a cookie-cutter doesn’t mean you can’t have something original in the end.

Art:
            Matt Frank (with colors by Thomas Deer) does a great job of blending different Transformers styles that we have come to enjoy from the more than meets the eye and robots in disguise titles.  We get the open forms and muted colors coupled with the cartoony nature of the titles that creates an overall sense of continuity.  I am definitely a fan of that style, especially on these titles, and Frank does an exceptional job of making this feel almost like an episode of a cartoon show as opposed to a comic book.

            The one thing that leads to confusion is the fact that many of the panel borders are razor thin lines of color, which do very little to separate the panels, and the action therein, from its surroundings.  With characters that have so many moving parts and little details, even in a cartoony style, expanding those panel border would go a long way to increasing the clarity of the comic.  It would also be more beneficial (in my mind at least) if Frank had stuck to more of a grid in terms of his panels, or at least not done so much with inset panels.  I don’t see a real benefit of every page being all inset panels within one or two larger ones, especially given the fact that the borders don’t separate them. 

As you can see, it all gets fairly jumbled, especially on pages where the colors are so similar throughout.  Breaking the barely-there panel borders doesn't help either.


The slanted panels at the bottom are unnecessary.  Thomas Deer does do a decent job of changing up the way the interior and exterior of the ship is colored, but all the inset panels can and do lead to some confusion.

7/10 – The art on the page is very good; it’s just how that art is presented that is not as effective.  The thought is there, but the execution doesn’t follow the idea to completion.  Frank is a very talented artist though and if he doesn’t try to get too fancy with his layouts I think he would be better served.

Overall: 8/10 – Like many of the Transformers comics currently being published, this one doesn’t disappoint.  


Thursday, February 21, 2013

Comic Review – Vitriol The Hunter #1


            First, a mini-rant:

            I walked into my comic shop today, and it was like I was transported back in time to 1992.  Someone at DC Comics had dusted off their flux capacitor and decided that Justice League of America needed not one, not two, not three, but fifty-two variant covers.  Okay, DC, you guys are idiots, and your marketing department should be forced to physically consume the leftover copies of this stupidity.  When I first heard the news of the variant covers I thought it was dumb, but now that I see them in person I realize just how ridiculous they are.  Here is the thing, my comic shop, and I’m assuming any other shop of a similar size or larger, moved comics out of the way so that an entire shelf could be devoted to these covers.  I have never worked in retail, but I know how important shelf space is, and the fact that regular inventory was moved to make room for God knows how many copies of one comic is just stupid.  They are all the same damn thing just with a different cover (and not even a markedly different cover, just a different flag cut and pasted in photoshop)! 

            Not only that, but I went into the shop yesterday in a pretty decent mood.  My pull list was pretty light but there is one thing that really got me excited, the newest Goon trade was out!  I was going to be able to follow along with Goon and Franky while they did whatever it was they were going to do.  Did that happen?  Nope.  No Goon.  I am hoping against hope it was just an oversight and not because the entire comic budget for the shop was spent on 150 copies of the newest superhero garbage from DC. 

            Anyway, on to this week’s review: Vitriol The Hunter #1.

Cover:
            It’s a first issue, so the montage cover actually works pretty well here.  The cover was drawn by the interior artist so that is a major plus as well because what you see artistically is what you get throughout (I’ll go into that more in depth in the art section of the review).  The cover itself fits the subject matter very well in terms of the tone that it sets forth.  The best part about it is the fact that they didn’t try to put any color or tone in the actual title itself.  The cover itself is so dark with its predominantly purple and blue hues that anything but white would have blended too much into the background.  The title itself is clear and easy to read.  It doesn’t interfere with the art and just sits there, doing its job as it is supposed to.

            The art does a decent job of telling me who the good guys and bad guys are.  At least the vampires don’t sparkle.

5/10 – A middle of the road cover.  The title is good but the art itself doesn’t really do anything else that stands out.

Story:
            I really want to read a good vampire story to reclaim the genre from the Twilight kids.  I was hoping that this was going to be one that brings the characters of vampires back to being scary and sinister and not caricatures.  The vampires themselves are okay, a little cheesy but not terrible representations.  They are a bit stereotypical of the kind of vampires we would see before vampires had “feelings” or whatever has happened to them of late.  The whole secret society thing can be done well and it’s nice that writers Billy Martin and Brent Allen have given them specific idiosyncrasies that they have expanded upon in footnotes.  This helps to make the vampires more their own creations as opposed to just copies of something they saw in a Wesley Snipes movie. 

            That all goes away when one of the vampires is named Korbius though.  Really?  Korbius?  As in Morbius from Marvel comics but with a “K”?  Wow.  That is within the first few pages and it is easy to see that this comic goes from a reclamation project for the vampire genre to pretty damn formulaic in a hurry.  The way that the vampires talk, especially big boss vampire is very clichéd and offers nothing fresh.  From there it gets worse because we are introduced to the main character and he is automatically shoved down our throats as some kind of bad-ass (with no pupils, not really sure what that’s about).  He’s a take no prisoners kind of guy that, after he is injured, gets patched up by a girl that will either become his girlfriend or his damsel in distress (or both) before all is said and done.  Of course her father used to do the same thing for him, and of course there is some kind of magical pill that he takes to help him.

            If you haven’t noticed, there’s a lot of “of course that happened” kind of moments in this.

            We then move to fight scene where the vampires are attacking some cops that look to be dressed in the kinds of uniforms you usually associate with German or Soviet troops circa 1945.  Surprise surprise, these troops are getting massacred until Vitriol shows up and saves the day.  We then get treated to a montage of Vitriol fighting the vampires and…meh.  It’s just boring and uninspiring.  The fight ends and we get more quips and shots of Vitriol that are supposed to make us think he is cool or a badass, but all I am reminded of is Carson Daly.  Someone that really wants to and really tries to be cool but is just a tool.  Oh, and of course we are introduced to some kind of magic serum that creates werewolves (which they call Lycans here because of course they do) and find out that that is what the vampire horde was after the whole time. 

1/10 – The story is full of coincidences and “of course that happened” moments.  Nothing feels original, and the extra effort to make Vitriol into some kind of bad ass that doesn’t respect authority etc. etc. is just sad.  How did this comic ever get green-lit?

Art:
            It’s obvious that Billy Martin is a fan of Humberto Ramos.  In fact he may be trying a little too hard to be Ramos as I am pretty sure there is at least one panel that I remember from Ramos’s work in the past (I think it’s from Crimson but not too sure).  That’s the thing, this book is just trying too hard to be Crimson, and it’s not doing a good job of it.  Art-wise, the perspective and the anatomy is way off and not in an exaggerated style like we would normally see from someone like Ramos, but in a WTF kind of style where the artist just obviously screwed it up.  Heads and limbs don’t look like they rest on the characters in the right places and the one girl in the whole comic is drawn like she has no internal organs (or lower ribs for that matter).  A decent job is done in terms of drawing backgrounds and establishing where things are taking place, but that doesn’t save the art when it is supposed to be relatively action oriented. 

Two shining examples of heads that just don't seem to be connected to the bodies that they are on.  And why is Vitriol standing like that while shooting someone?  That's not natural at all.

That middle panel looks off in terms of the perspective of the window.  If that was accurate the vampire would have to be practically laying down.  A good idea but with poor execution.

How many organs did she have removed so she could get her waist that small?  And the panel all the way to the right, her hand should be moved to his other shoulder because there is no way she should be able to be turned the way she is turned but still position her arm that far back.

No wonder they can't defeat the vampires, this gut doesn't even watch where he's shooting.

I have seen the face in the inset panel before.  Plus you have the exclamation of Vitriol's name after the text that it's supposed to precede.  Piss poor job of layout.

I have seen this exact panel in a Ramos comic before (I think it was Crimson).  This looks like it was poorly lightboxed from that comic.

Stuff like this is supposed to make him sound bad-ass but just makes him sound like a douche.

You are holding what is presumably a glass vial of something that changes people into werewolves, or something like that.  Why would you be squeezing it like that?  It looks like he's beating off, not holding a delicate, possibly earth shattering find.

2/10 – It’s almost as if Billy Martin sat down with a complete collection of Crimson and just made a fan comic of it, a pretty poorly done one at that.  Again, how does something like this get green-lit?  Is it because people will hopefully look at the cover and see a Ramos style and vampires and get duped into thinking it’s Crimson 2.0?

Overall: 2/10 – This was just not a good comic all around.  The story was formulaic and forced and the art lacked basic drawing skills, instead preferring to ape a style that took years to perfect all of the little things that make it stand out.  The coloring is good but if I wanted to buy a comic strictly for the coloring I would seek out the colorist’s portfolio.  It just leaves me very disappointed.


Thursday, February 7, 2013

Comic Review – Transformers: More than meets the eye #13


            I know, you’ve been holding your breath for this review for a month now.  Well breathe easy because it is here and the comic itself was well worth the wait.  I have yet to pour through my stack of comics this week yet, but it was a banner week for IDW’s Transformers franchise as it saw three titles released along with the new issue of Think Tank and the Paul Jenkins/Humberto Ramos Kickstarter monster known as Fairy Quest (now picked up and released by Boom Studios).  I can’t speak to the quality of the other comics out this week, but I know that Transformers: MTMTE is top notch, let’s dive in shall we?


Cover:
            Cover A featured the Transformers found in the issue in their human guises (a solid hologram that can be used to seamlessly blend into a crowd of humans or other aliens.  Cover B, the one that I purchased, was the image above.  Both covers actually take place within the story so that is a bonus.  The cover that I picked up was well done even though it was slightly misleading.  I was under the assumption that Cyclonus, who I am just waiting for to betray the bunch, finally lost it and it was up to the other members of the Lost Light to subdue.  This is pretty far from the truth, but he does lose his cool in one part of the story (for a couple panels) so while it was sneaky by artist Nick Roche, it was not a blatant lie to get people to pick up the book.  The artwork itself is very well done (as we have grown to expect from Roche) and each character seems to be exuding a bit of his own personality with their respective body language and facial expression.  Roche has become a master of taking traditionally blocky figures and imbuing them with a level of fluid movement and emotion that is hard to believe is even possible.  He is definitely one of the best Transformers artists currently working and when paired with a good colorist, like he is with Josh Burcham here on the cover (who also colors the interiors) then his work is kicked up a whole other notch. 

8/10 – A solid illustration made even better by the coloring.

Story:
            Swerve tends to be writer James Roberts’ mouthpiece for many of the issues, and this one especially.  This is a good thing as he has taken Swerve from a supporting character and made him the focal point of the buddy-comedy that he has created with MTMTE.  Not only that, but each other character on the Lost Light (the spaceship they are all travelling on) has his own distinct personality as well as their own specific mission (some have yet to be revealed).  This particular story focuses on a “quiet” period, where the individual members of the lost light are let off the ship for a little R & R. 

            Crazy antics ensue (which always seems to happen to these guys) as well as some revelations about Swerve, Ultra Magnus and Tailgate.  Roberts balances humor, talking heads, and a good deal of emotion and still finds a way to move the story forward.  This is the kind of done-in-one story that we used to see all the time back in the eighties and early nineties and it is a revelation to be able to sit down and enjoy a comic that takes longer than eight minutes to read.
            The best part of the comic is the revelation about Swerve and his “friendship” with Blurr at the end.  This adds another dimension to the character and while it was unexpected, was a welcome addition. 

            Now it isn’t all roses as Roberts does tend to get a little wordy in some places, but he does manage to balance that out with some silent panels here and there, little beats where we can catch our breath and enjoy the artwork. 

            I can’t talk about the writing here without also mentioning the prose story in the back that takes an instance in the comic and expands upon it, while also filling in the gaps between issues nicely.  Other writers and other companies would have taken that four page story and made it into a six issues, but Roberts wedges it in quite nicely.  Is it necessary to read it in order to enjoy this issue?  Not at all, but it is nice to be able to have anything extra on hand from an individual like Roberts who obviously knows and loves the property. 

8/10 – While it is not a page-turner by any means, it is a solid character driven story that expands upon the individuals and fits in nicely in the series.  This is the calm before the storm as next issue will reveal a big villain for the crew if I remember correctly.

Art:
            Guido Guidi is the artist on this issue and his style seems to mesh well with the style that Roche has established for the series.  Guidi has a very open style that leaves a lot of room for the colorist (Burcham and Joana LaFuente) to add layers and mood.  It keeps an animated feel, which is nice considering the roots of the franchise, but does not make it feel like a children’s comic.  It is incredibly accessible to everyone as kids will be attracted to the characters and the color while the parents will enjoy the decent storytelling in the artwork as well as the story itself. 

            The artwork can seem to get a little overwhelmed by amount of detail that Guidi squeezes into each panel and each page, as he, and in some instances the colorists, don’t always do a great job of separating the fore/middle/backgrounds.  This leads to a bit of confusion every once in awhile and can lead to moments of sub-par storytelling, but it quickly rights itself and never gets stuck in a rut. 

7/10 – The artwork fits the story and Guidi does a great job as a fill-in for Roche in terms of keeping the styles fairly consistent as well as keeping the characters fluid and emotive throughout the story. 

Overall:  8/10 – This is still the gem of all of the current Transformers books, just as it has been from the beginning.  Robots in Disguise is quickly catching up, as that was more of a slow-burn in terms of getting where it wanted to be but I have a feeling that with next month’s issue, MTMTE will cement its position even further.  It’s nice to anticipate comic again like I did in my youth, and all of the IDW Transformers series do that for me.